Training should be fun and rewarding, but many don’t realize they’re making things TOUGHER for when you need help. Whether you have a young puppy, a senior dog, or even a cat for that matter — unlike what many may think — avoiding pet training mistakes can mean the difference between success and disappointment.
These errors — well they’re a part of pet parenthood for all of us: From the rookies who are getting their first dog or cat to old pros. The good news? Once you are aware of what it is that you’re doing wrong, fixing it can be simple.
In this guide, we are going to cover the eight largest pet training mistakes that may be standing in your way and how you can fix them.
Mistake #1: Failing to Be Consistent When Giving Commands/Rules
Consistency is key to successful pet training. When you vary your commands, rules, or responses from day to day, your pet becomes unsure about what you really want.
Why Inconsistency Frustrates Your Pet
Imagine if your boss told you to do something one way on Monday, then reprimanded you for doing it that same way on Tuesday. That’s exactly what your pet thinks when you’re being inconsistent. Dogs and cats are creatures of habit. They never know what to think is getting rewarded if the patterns keep shifting.
Popular Inconsistency Issues
Too many cooks with their own command spoil the broth. And one person says “down” and another person says “lie down” and we both mean the same thing. These are all totally distinct commands as far as your pet is concerned. Likewise letting your pooch on the couch sometimes but not other times is sending a confusing message.
The Fix
Pick one command for each behavior and make sure everyone in your household is using the same word. Write out your rules and send them to family members. If pets are not allowed on furniture, they can’t jump up only when we’re in a good mood.
Here’s a list of what simple training chart should include:
- Exact commands to give your dog
- How to use hand signals for each command
- What behaviors are accepted and which ones aren’t
- Consequences they will face for breaking the rules
Mistake #2: Rewarding Bad Behavior Without Realizing It
This is one of those subtle pet training mistakes that you don’t even realize when you’re doing it. Every single time your pet does something and then gets attention, food or play immediately afterward, their brain is connecting those dots.
How Accidental Rewards Occur
You walk in the door and your dog leaps on you. You push them down as you talk to them, eye contact is important. To your dog, that’s time and engagement… the very thing they hoped for. You just rewarded jumping.
It is 5 in the morning and your cat loudly meows. You rise and you give them some food to make them quiet. Now your cat has learned that meowing at dawn equals breakfast. You’ve conditioned them to rise and shine well before you do.
Breaking the Reward Cycle
Only pay attention, treats or play when your pet is calm and obedient. Stand with your back to the dog and pay him no attention at all if they jump up. Once the second set of all four paws are placed on the ground, offer praise and pets.
Don’t make a big deal of problem behaviors, either — just wait ’em out. Yes, it’s hard when your cat won’t shut up or your dog keeps yapping. But if you do give in, you’re teaching them that persistence is rewarded.
Mistake #3: Punishing After the Fact
Coming home and screaming at your dog because he chewed up your couch just doesn’t do anything. It’s a very important pet training mistake that hurts your relationship and doesn’t get anything done.
Delayed Punishment
Pets are creatures of the moment. There is a 2-3 second window in which they are able to associate an action with a consequence. Minutes or hours later, when you punish them, they have no clue what you are so upset about. They just know you are angry, and that makes them anxious and fearful.
That “guilty look” you see is not guilt. It is your pet reacting to your angry body language and tone. They are cowering because they feel your anger, not because they recall destroying the couch.
The Right Way
In order to successfully redirect behavior, you must get your pet to act while you are there seeing it. If you come across a mess afterward, clean it up and don’t give it another thought.
Focus on prevention of future problems by:
- Better managing your pet’s environment
- Providing the right outlets for his energy
- Supervising more — until good habits form
- Rewarding “good” in a consistent manner
Mistake #4: Too-Long Training Sessions
You end up more tired than when you started if you try to cram all of your training into marathon sessions. Short bursts of targeted practice are far more effective than long lectures no one enjoys.
The Fact of the Attention Span
Most dogs can focus on training for 5-15 minutes at a time, depending on their age and energy level. Puppies have even shorter attention spans, sometimes only 2-3 (if that). Cats usually cap out at 5 minutes before they are over you.
When you approach these limits, your pet stops learning and becomes frustrated. They get things wrong, you get frustrated and suddenly training is a chore for all.
Ideal Training Timing
| Animal Type | Length of Time/Session | Sessions/Day | Total Daily Training |
|---|---|---|---|
| Puppies (under 6 months) | 3-5 minutes | 4-6 sessions | 15-30 minutes |
| Adult Dogs | 10-15 minutes | 2-3 sessions | 20-45 minutes |
| Senior Dogs | 5-10 minutes | 2-3 sessions | 15-30 minutes |
| Cats (all ages) | 3-5 minutes | 2-4 sessions | 10-20 minutes |
If your pet is having difficulty with a new command, revert back to something they’ve mastered, allow them the moment of succeeding and reward, then end.
Mistake #5: Skipping the Basics for Advanced Training
Trying to get your dog to roll over or play dead when they don’t even know “sit” reliably sets up everyone for failure. We’re on the road to better pet training by preventing hundreds of those mistakes.
Why Basic Commands Are Useful
Basic commands are not mere parlor tricks. They are communication tools that keep your pet safe and make daily life more convenient. A good solid “come” could save your dog’s life if he escapes near a road. A good “stay” will keep them from rushing out of an open door.
Each basic command also trains your pet to learn. They discover that thinking about you, experimenting with behaviors and responding to cues produces good stuff. Teaching advanced skills goes so much faster.
Primary Fundamentals of the Game
Learn these before you work on your advanced training:
- Name: Your pet should pay attention to you when you speak the pet’s name
- Sit: The foundation for just about everything else
- Stay: Impulse control and patience
- Come: Crucial for safety and off-leash trust
- Drop It: Encourages your pet to release dangerous items
- Down: May assist with calming and settling
Take your time with these. Before you consider a command “learned,” your pet should be able to perform the same way in several different locations, even when there are distractions, 80-90% of the time.
Mistake #6: Not Tailoring Training To Your Pet’s Personality
Every pet is unique. One of the biggest pet training mistakes is why it doesn’t work even with “scared” dogs. Using this exact same approach with a dog that is confident and outgoing can actually backfire on you.
Interpreting Your Pet’s Cues
Some pets are food-driven and will do anything for treats. Others don’t even care about the snacks but love to get their praise from a toy or a pet. Some animals are brazen, and require tough, clear lines of demarcation. Others are sensitive, and will shut down if you’re too stern.
Pay attention to your dog during training. Are they excited and engaged? Or worried and hesitant? Are they easily distracted, or are you the complete focus of their attention?
Tailoring Your Approach
For High-Energy Pets:
- Use brief sessions and play- or chase-based rewards
- Shorten your sessions even more while they’re young
- Exercise before training to take the edge off
- Try higher-value treats – like chicken, cheese, and hot dogs
For Shy or Fearful Pets:
- Keep training loving but have realistic expectations about their comfort zone – you may never have a party animal dog
- Reward little improvements as soon as they happen
- Don’t be pushy or force them beyond their limits
For Stubborn Independent Pets:
- Make training feel more “game-like” than “work-like” (but do give them clear rules and boundaries)
- Bring out those high-value treats you’ve been hoarding – think steak, sausage & sardines
- Use the showdown concept and separate them into trainers for learning
Mistake #7: Only Training in One Location
There’s a very good reason why you are having this problem and it happens to be one of the most widespread mistakes pet owners make: Training in only one environment.
Why Location Matters
All skills are not created equal: Pets do not generalize skills from one environment to another. If you only do it at home, he learns “sit when we’re in the living room” as opposed to “sit means sit everywhere.” Every new place comes with its own set of sights, sounds and smells that draw your pet away.
Thinking of getting a dog for your apartment? 🏠 See the best breeds here.
Developing Real-World Reliability
Practice in real-world nontraining situations. Once your pet is excelling in the easier places, you can increase difficulty:
Level 1 (Easy):
- Room at home where there’s not much going on
- Known backyard space
- Early morning when others are still asleep
Level 2 (Moderate):
- Different rooms of your house
- Front yard with occasional passing people
- Quieter side-streets or alleys
Level 3 (Hard):
- Pet-friendly shops during off-hours
- Parks at low-traffic times
- Near playgrounds or areas with lots of people/traffic
- Occasionally busy sidewalks
Level 4 (Expert):
- Local dog parks
- Downtown pedestrian walks
- When near exciting stimuli like squirrels or other animals
Move up one level only once your pet has mastered a level 80% of the time. If they don’t, drop back down until you are feeling good again.
Mistake #8: Not Showing Up For Training
It takes time to train. Lots of time. Wanting immediate results and giving up when you don’t get it is perhaps the most tragic of all the pet training mistakes, because what will be lost is oh-so-minuscule compared to what is gained through creating an incredible bond with proper training.
Realistic Training Durations
Not all skills are learned at the same rate. Here’s what that actually looks like:
Basic Commands (Sit, Down, Stay):
- Initial understanding: 1-2 weeks
- Reliable response at home: 4-6 weeks
- Works in distracting environments: 2-4 months
Problem Behaviors (Jumping, Barking, Pulling on Leash):
- Seeing first improvements: 2-4 weeks
- Significant progress: 6-12 weeks
- Completely resolved: 3-6 months or beyond
House Training:
- Puppies reach full daytime control between four and six months of age
- They will be reliable all the time by eight to twelve months of age
- Adult dogs learning new rules can take four to eight weeks
Staying Motivated Through Plateaus
Progress isn’t linear. You’ll have some good weeks followed by some frustrating ones in which everyone just seems to fall apart. It’s perfectly normal, and doesn’t mean you’re doing a bad job.
Track small progress in a training journal. Be sure to record:
- What you practiced every day
- Your pet’s best moments
- Things you are struggling with
- Any questions for either your trainer or vet
Looking back weeks and months, you can see improvement that is unseen by the naked eye. Celebrate small successes, such as your dog maintaining a stay for an extra 5 seconds, or your cat coming when called once more.
Developing Your Pet Training Success Plan
So now you know what not to do when it comes to pet training, let’s develop a simple plan that will guarantee you success.
Week 1-2: Foundational Phase
- Choose one simple command to focus on
- Train for three to five minutes, three times a day
- Use your pet’s favorite treats
- Practice in a quiet environment only
- Get everyone in your home on board
Week 3-4: Building Reliability
- Continue practicing daily sessions with high-value rewards, such as hot dogs or cheese, for good work
- Begin adding mild distractions while training at least two different rooms in your house to really develop this new skill
- Be sure to reward correct responses each time
- Introduce a second basic need-to-know command
Week 5-8: Adding Difficulty
- Your pooch does well and is consistently being responsive at his current level of training and moving up into the next gear
- Make sure that you practice both inside your home (where typical doggie mischief happens) but also your yard or local park where there are more potential distractions
- Practice around other folks off property while taking great strides with positive reinforcement teaching
- Work on greater distances between you and pets
- Try combining multiple commands
Frequently Asked Questions
How much training time should I commit to per day?
15 to 30 minutes of training per day in several practice sessions. Three 5-minute sessions are better than one 15-minute marathon. Puppies and kittens can handle even shorter sessions of 2-5 minutes.
But my pet already has these bad habits?
Yes, you can retrain a pet with entrenched bad habits, but it will take longer than preventing the problem to begin with. Plan on retraining to take 2-3 times as long as the initial training. Consistency and patience are key.
Should I use treats forever?
Treats will help your dog pick up new behaviors fast, but you shouldn’t rely on them indefinitely. Once a command is solid, you can slowly begin to replace some of the treats with praise and petting. Reserve treats for special occasions and use them as surprise rewards.
My pet obeys at home, but ignores me in the park. What’s wrong?
Nothing is wrong. There’s nothing wrong with you, it’s because you haven’t trained in a noisy environment yet. Work up into outdoor training slowly, similarly to how you gradually add distractions according to Mistake #7.
How do I know if I’m being too hard or not hard enough?
Watch your pet’s body language. If they’re ready and willing to train, engaging in eye contact and experimenting with different behaviors, you’ve wired your approach properly. If they’re avoiding you, clamming up or look stressed out, you may be being too strict. If they’re ignoring you and doing as they please, then you need some firmer boundaries in place.
Can old dogs (or cats) learn new behaviors?
Absolutely! You can indeed teach an old dog new tricks—that saying you can’t is a load of crap. Older pets are just as capable of learning — they may require more repetition and patience. The rules of the school remain the same no matter how old you get!
Ending Your Training Journey
Once you remove these pet training mistakes, your relationship with your adorable friend will change completely. Never forget, training is not about perfection – it’s all about communication, trust and reinforcing the bond between you both.
All pets have individual learning curves. Some learn new skills in days, while others take weeks. The most important thing is for you to be consistent, patient and positive through it all.
Begin by choosing any one mistake on this list and concentrate your efforts to fix that. Maybe you’ll decide to commit to shorter training walks or get everyone on the same page with some commands. It’s the small things… that accumulate over time to make a big difference.
Training your pet is one of the greatest investments you can make. A well-behaved pet is a safer, happier, and more enjoyable pet! They also experience more, are limited less and learn confidence that can help their entire life.
Your mistakes don’t make you any less of a pet owner. All that really matters is that you’re here, learning, and resolved to be better. Your pet doesn’t need a great trainer – your pet needs a dedicated trainer who keeps coming back, and doing their best, and learning alongside of them.
